If your house hasn't sold yet, it may be overpriced

Dated: December 14 2023

Views: 87

house with stacked rock on left side, tan siding, and dark gray roofHas your house been sitting on the market a while without selling? If so, you should know that’s pretty unusual, even right now. That’s because the supply of homes available for sale is still far lower than what we’d see in a normal year. That means buyers have fewer options than they usually would, so your house should be an oasis in an inventory desert. So, if homebuyers have limited choices and your house still hasn’t sold, there’s a reason why. Let’s break one potential sticking point that may be turning buyers away: your asking price. Especially with mortgage rates higher than the last three years already putting a stretch on their budget, buyers are being a bit more sensitive about price. As a recent article from the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) says:
If you are serious about selling your home now, don’t get greedy with the asking price. This is still a seller’s home market as there simply aren’t enough affordable homes for sale in many parts of the country. But with average 30-year mortgage rates above 6%, buyers are much more price sensitive than they were a year ago.”

Why Setting the Right Price Matters

While you want to maximize the return on your investment when you sell your house, you also need to be realistic based on current market conditions. The simple truth is your house is only going to sell for what people are willing to pay right now. This can be a hard thing to accept. Especially since emotions can run high during the selling process, which only complicates matters more. After all, you may have lived in this house for years, so it’s only natural to be emotionally tied to it—and those attachments can make it harder to be objective.  But it’s important to acknowledge that a bigger-than-expected price tag deters buyers and may make them dismiss your house as a possibility before even seeing it. And if no one’s looking at it, how will it sell? If you want to get your house sold, you’ll need to do something to spark interest in your home again. That’s where a local real estate agent comes in. We help by using data to find out if it’s priced too high for your local market. There are other factors like quality of photography, video and social reach that affect its marketability, however price is always the foundation by which buyers select a house. We balance the value of homes in your neighborhood, current market trends and buyer demand, the condition of your house and more to find the right price for your house, so you can close this chapter and start the next one.

Bottom Line

While it’s true there aren’t that many homes available for sale right now, your home’s asking price still matters. And if it’s not selling, it may be priced too high. 
Blog author image

Steve Reese

With 30+ years of experience in Oklahoma real estate, I help buyers, sellers, and rightsizers make smart, meaningful moves in Shawnee, OKC, and across Central Oklahoma. I combine deep market expertise....

Latest Blog Posts

Selling Your Shawnee Home Without an Agent? Start Here.

A plain-English resource for Shawnee home sellers who want to go it alone and do it rightI’m a REALTOR®. I make my living helping people buy and sell homes in Shawnee and Central Oklahoma.

Read More

Home inspections: What Sellers Should Expect

Once your home is under contract, we move into the inspection period outlined in the Oklahoma Uniform Residential Sale Contract. This is a normal phase of the transaction. Knowing how it works ahead

Read More

Shawnee Housing Market 2025 Year in Review. What the Headlines Missed

If you only followed national housing headlines in 2025, you probably heard a lot of noise. Interest rates. Market slowdowns. Buyer hesitation. Depending on the week, the story swung from &ldquo

Read More

Why I Measure Success in Trust, Not Transactions

Real Estate Beyond the ScoreboardEvery January, real estate social feeds start to look the same. Photos of plaques. Rankings. Sales awards. Captions celebrating volume and thanking clients and

Read More